Ledger Market-Unit Mortgage

Mortgage calculator

Two loans: one in dollars, one in market units.

You want to buy a house. You work in big tech.You vest equity. But you worry about market crash.

Your salary carries less. Your equity does what it would have done anyway, without the price risk on that slice.

How the two loans work

Split the mortgage in two. The big part is an ordinary 30-year loan in dollars, paid from salary. The small part — sized to the equity you'll vest over the next few years — is a short loan in S&P 500 units at a 2.5% margin, repaid from your vesting as it comes in. When the market falls, that part of your debt falls with it. After the vesting window it's gone.

Both loans are recorded at closing, like an ordinary piggyback structure; the money goes to the seller, the obligations stay with you.

Already own? New job, new grant, old mortgage: the same split works as a refinance. A market-unit second loan, sized to the vesting ahead, pays down the first; the first is recast over its remaining term. Choose "Already own" in the calculator.

Explore whether this fits

From the March 2000 closing peak, through the dot-com sell-off and recovery.

From the closing peak

Mar 24, 2000

Deepest fall within your window

-47.4%

Total return includes dividends. Low on Oct 9, 2002. Payments use monthly observations; the drop above includes the daily low.

Source: S&P 500 Total Return on Yahoo Finance

Annual summaries · the calculation follows the monthly history

%
%
%
Assumes your equity tracks the index.

During the drawdown

At the lowest monthly index level, B owes $114,384 less than D.

Month 30 · Sep 24, 2002. Both have made the same payments. Recovery can change the comparison by the end of the window.

Same dollars out every month, two ways to owe them

After year 3 you owe $115,931 less with the market-unit loan than by prepaying a dollar loan.

D · one dollar loan, prepaid from vesting

$935,478

left after year 3 · then $6,133/mo

Moves with the market: the prepayments are whatever your vested shares fetch.

B · two loans, dollars + market units

$819,547

left after year 3 · then $5,373/mo

Fixed on every path: the market-unit loan is gone, the traditional loan is where its schedule says.

Debt left, month by month

B and D send the same dollars every month, so their payments look identical. The difference is in what is left to owe. B counts the market-unit loan at its current dollar value.

A · one loanD · prepaidB · ours
Debt left over time for A, D and BB and D make the same payments during the vesting window. At its end, D owes $935,478 and B owes $819,547.$600k$800k$1m$1.2m$1.4mYear 3 · vesting endsClosingYear 3Year 6Debt left over time for A, D and BB and D make the same payments during the vesting window. At its end, D owes $935,478 and B owes $819,547.$600k$800k$1m$1.2m$1.4mYear 3 · vesting endsClosingYear 3Year 6

At the end of year 3: D $935,478 vs B $819,547 — +$115,931 in B's favour.

Side by side

A: one 6.50% loan on $1,200,000. D: the same loan, paying B's amounts during the window. B: $850,000 at 6.50% + $350,000 in S&P 500 units at 2.5% over the index.

A · one loanD · prepaidB · ours
Month 1 · from salary
$7,585$5,373$5,373
Month 1 · from vesting
$0$9,462$9,462
Month 1 · total
$7,585$14,835$14,835
Peak month in years 1–3
$7,585$15,394$15,394
Debt left after year 3
$1,157,007$935,478$819,547
Monthly payment after year 3
$7,585$6,133$5,373
30-year total paid
$2,730,534$2,458,765$2,212,528

Where B's difference from A comes from, on the $350,000 slice

Paying it off in 3 years instead of 30

+$410,228

Interest avoided, nominal. Mostly money spent earlier; D gets the same.

Market units instead of dollars

+$107,778

vs a 3-year dollar loan at 6.50%: the index rose slower than the rate.

Tax on repaying less than borrowed

−$29,324

$71,600 shortfall taxed at your marginal rate (≈41.0%).

The 6.5% is a rate on a dollar loan. The 2.5% is a margin over the index — the charge on top of a unit that already carries the market's return. They are not the same kind of number.

Historical crashes, then steady markets

The two-loan structure (B) under each path. "Units vs dollars" compares the market-unit loan with a dollar loan at the same rate over the same window, after tax on any shortfall; the bar is how much less (+, green) or more (−, red) you owe after the window with B than with D, one dollar loan prepaid by the same amounts. Stronger colors mean larger differences; near-zero values stay grey. Paths are not weighted by likelihood.

Assumes your equity tracks the index.
Index pathB month 1Units vs dollars, after taxB vs D: debt left after the window

Peak Mar 24, 2000-47.4% to the low in your window

$14,835+$78,453
+$115,931

Peak Oct 9, 2007-55.3% to the low in your window

$14,769+$84,141
+$129,120

Peak May 21, 2015-12.8% to the low in your window

$15,391−$18,875
−$17,652

Peak Feb 19, 2020-33.8% to the low in your window

$12,574−$42,244
−$43,941

Peak Jan 3, 2022-24.5% to the low in your window

$14,811+$26,191
+$31,828
$15,491+$11,196
+$12,722
$15,531−$18,149
−$18,520
$15,570−$48,987
−$51,301

What to know

  1. On average it is not cheaper. Over the window the market-unit loan costs fewer dollars than a 6.5% dollar loan would only if the index returns under about 3.9% a year. Since 1999 that happened in roughly one three-year window in four.
  2. What you get instead is a match. When the market falls, that slice of your debt falls with it — by the same amount as the vesting that was going to pay it. It is insurance on money that is already spoken for, not a discount.
  3. The units are owed whether or not you still vest. The program expects a year at your employer first, and sizes the loan to the vesting that is left — at most three years. If you leave before it is repaid, the shares that already vested have gone to the loan; what remains is still owed in units, paid from salary or refinanced into a dollar loan at that day's rate. Keep the second loan small enough that savings could cover it.
  4. As a refinance it only makes sense on an expensive first loan. Paying down a 3% mortgage from 2021 with a loan at index + 2.5% trades cheap debt for dear. On a 2022–2025 loan at 6.5–7.5% the match costs little; add closing costs on the second loan to the comparison.
  5. Your equity is not the index. A single stock can fall while the S&P 500 rises. The match is only as good as the fit between your grant and the index.
  6. If you repay fewer dollars than you borrowed, the shortfall is taxable income — the after-tax line above already deducts it. Treatment of the unit loan's cost is not settled; ask a tax adviser.

Would you take this loan?

We're gauging interest before launch. Tell us which version you'd want and we'll be in touch when it's available.

Which version interests you?

We'll only use your email to contact you about this program.